TRIIAL CASE
Italy, Court of Cassation, n. 8906, supreme court istance, 14 May 2020
Deciding court: Court of Cassation
Topic: Judicial involvement in politics
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): Not a direct follow up
ECtHR jurisprudence: ECHR (articles 6, 7, 9, 11, 14) European Court of Human Rights 16 October 2018, Daineliene v. Lithuania; 31 October 2017, Kamenos v. Cyprus; 20 September 2016, Karelin v. Russia; 23 April 2015, Morice v. France; 15 January 2015, Dragojevic v. Croatia.
TRIIAL CASE
Italy, Superior Council of the Judiciary, n. 52, disciplinary instance, 18 March 2018
Deciding court: Superior Council of the Judiciary
Topic: Independence, accountability, impartiality (relationship between lawyers and judges, use of social media by judges, relations with the media)
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): Not a direct follow up
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
TRIIAL CASE
Italy, Court of Palermo, Section for immigration, international protection and free movement of citizens of the European Union, ordinary instance, Decree of 27 August 2024
Deciding court: Court of Palermo
Topic: Mutual trust
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): N/A
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
TRIIAL CASE
Italy, Tribunal of Milan, FR v. Ministero dell’Interno, ordinary instance, 9/5/2018
Deciding court: Tribunal of Milan
Topic: Impartiality (Conflict of Interest)Rule of law (Fair Trial/ Access to Justice)
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): The national case is a direct follow up of the CJEU order of 27 September 2018
ECtHR jurisprudence: Article 3 ECHRArticle 6 ECHRArticle 13 ECHRECtHR judgments:Gebremedhin v. France of 26 April 2007Hirsi Jamaa v. Italy of 23 February 2012Krombach v. France of 13 February 2001Annoni v. France of 14 November 2000
TRIIAL CASE
Italy, Court of Catania (Tribunale di Catania), no. 4117/2023, immigration section, ordinary instance, Decree of 29 September 2023
Deciding court: Court of Catania
Topic: Mutual trust
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): N/A
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
TRIIAL CASE
Italy, Court of Catania, Immigration section, R.G. no. 9543/2024, Decree of 20 September 2024
Deciding court: Court of Catania
Topic: Mutual trust
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): N/A
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
TRIIAL CASE
Italy, Supreme Court of Cassation, civil section, united sections, no. 9042/2019, supreme instance, 1/4/2019
Deciding court: Supreme Court of Cassation
Topic: Impartiality (conflict of interest);Independence (appearance of independence)
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): Not a direct follow-up
ECtHR jurisprudence: Art. 6 ECHR
TRIIAL CASE
Italy, Court of Cassation, n. 27493/2013, supreme instance, 10 December 2013
Deciding court: Court of Cassation
Topic: Freedom of expression - Extrajudicial activities of judges
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): Not a direct follow up of a CJEU or ECtHR decision
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
TRIIAL CASE
Italy, Council of State, 8472/2019, supreme administrative instance, 13 December 2019
Deciding court: Council of State
Topic: Use of algorithms and artificial intelligence in administrative procedures
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): Not a direct follow up
ECtHR jurisprudence: No
TRIIAL CASE
Court of Justice, Case C‑700/21, O.G., 6 June 2023
Deciding court: Court of Justice (Grand Chamber)
Topic: Mutual trust
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): Preliminary ruling after two questions referred by the Italian Constitutional Court.
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
Project implemented with financial support of the Fundamental Rights & Citizenship Programme of the European Union
© European University Institute 2019
Villa Schifanoia - Via Boccaccio 121, I-50133 Firenze - Italy