TRIIAL CASE
Poland, Sąd Najwyższy - Professional Liability Chamber - Lieutenant Joanna T.
Deciding court: Supreme Court, Professional Liability Chamber. The chamber replaced in the Polish system the Disciplinary Chamber of the Supreme Court.
Topic: independence, impartiality
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): not applicable
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
TRIIAL CASE
Poland, Supreme Court - Request for a preliminary ruling from the Sąd Najwyższy (Poland) lodged on 26 November 2021, C-720/21
Deciding court: Supreme Court
Topic:
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): N/A
ECtHR jurisprudence: Dolinska-Ficek and Ozimek v. Poland, 8.11.2021
TRIIAL CASE
Poland, Sąd Rejonowy w Białymstoku, polish court case: VI P 6/23 CJEU C-146/23, ordinary
Deciding court: Regional Court in Białystok
Topic: Independence
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): N/A
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
TRIIAL CASE
Poland, Supreme Court, Chamber of Professional Liability, II ZOW 47/22, acting as appelate court
Deciding court: Supreme Court
Topic: Impartiality
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): N/A
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
TRIIAL CASE
Poland, Sąd Najwyższy (Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs Chamber), I NKRS 118/21, 12th January 2022, supreme
Deciding court: Supreme Court - Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs Chamber
Topic: independence, accountability
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): N/A
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
TRIIAL CASE
Poland, Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny (Supreme Administrative Court), case number II OSK 382/20, appellate instance, 11 January 2022
Deciding court: Supreme Administrative Court in Poland
Topic: mutual trust and impartiality
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): This national case is not a direct follow-up of a CJEU or ECtHR decision.
ECtHR jurisprudence: In the case under consideration, ECtHR jurisprudence was referred to indirectly by invoking the protection of fundamental rights, particularly through:Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), which prohibits inhuman or degrading treatment. This was referenced in relation to the risk of mistreatment upon the transfer of the applicant under the Dublin III Regulation.Article 8 of the ECHR was indirectly invoked concerning the right to respect for family life, which is relevant in assessing whether the transfer under the Dublin III Regulation could lead to a violation of family unity, given the applicant's marriage to a Polish national.In particular, the B.S. v. Spain and Tarakhel v. Switzerland cases are often cited in similar situations concerning the risk of human rights violations in the context of the Dublin transfers. However, the decision did not explicitly mention these cases, focusing more on the CJEU case law.
TRIIAL CASE
Poland, Regional Court in Hajnówka, ordinary, pending case on helping migrants on the border
Deciding court: Regional Court in Hajnówka
Topic: mutual trust
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): In a way - see case R.A. v. Poland available in the CJC database.
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
TRIIAL CASE
Poland, Gdańsk Court of Appeal, II Aka 261/22 appelate, 27th September 2022
Deciding court: Gdańsk Court of Appeal
Topic: Mutual Trust
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): (Indirect) follow up of C-221/19
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
TRIIAL CASE
Poland, ECtHR, Final decision - Żurek vs. Poland, 39650/18
Deciding court: ECtHR
Topic: freedom of expression
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): Not applicable
ECtHR jurisprudence: Grzęda v. Poland ([GC], no. 43572/18, §§ 257-264, 15 March 2022), Vilho Eskelinen and Others v. Finland ([GC], no. 63235/00, ECHR 2007‑II), Kudła v. Poland [GC], no. 30210/96, § 146, ECHR 2000‑XI, and Baka; Wille v. Liechtenstein ([GC], no. 28396/95, ECHR 1999‑VII); Kudeshkina v. Russia (no. 29492/05, 26 February 2009);
TRIIAL CASE
Poland, Supreme Administrative Court, II OSK 991/23, supreme, 07.11.2023
Deciding court: Supreme Administrative Court
Topic: Mutual trust
National Follow Up Of (when relevant): N/A
ECtHR jurisprudence: N/A
Project implemented with financial support of the Fundamental Rights & Citizenship Programme of the European Union
© European University Institute 2019
Villa Schifanoia - Via Boccaccio 121, I-50133 Firenze - Italy